🍁 Top 5 Customer-Favorite Syrups (And Why They’re Loved)

Our Syrup Hall of Fame—Ranked by You

Every flavor we make starts in our kitchen—but it lives or dies in yours.

We looked through your reviews, reorders, DMs, and those sweet “I need more!” emails to see what you really love. This list isn’t based on what we want to sell. It’s based on what you can’t get enough of.

So here they are—the five syrup flavors that have earned your loyalty, creativity, and coffee mugs.

🥇 #1: Maple Bourbon

Smooth maple with warm bourbon-caramel notes—without the alcohol.

“This syrup is soooo good! My favorite flavor is the Maple Bourbon – it’s perfect.” — Scott

💥 Dark Maple Bourbon (our top seller at markets) has a slightly richer flavor—sweeter, more intense maple, and a bit more depth.

Use it in:
☕️ Coffee
🍗 Chicken & waffles
🍿 Drizzled on popcorn
🍨 Over vanilla ice cream
🍸 Old Fashioned cocktails
🔥 Or a Cajun glaze like Oma’s—unreal.

🥈 #2: Cinnamon Vanilla

Warm cinnamon spice meets smooth, creamy vanilla. It’s comforting, versatile, and goes with almost anything.

“I used the cinnamon syrup in my apple pie… Everyone agreed it was the best pie I’ve ever made.” — MJ H.

A go-to for pancakes, lattes, chai tea, apple crisp—you name it.

🥉 #3: Lavender

Soft, floral, and surprisingly bold—Lavender has become a fan-favorite with serious staying power.

Our most popular flavor by far – Lavender! "Yep, that's the one!" (many market attendees who taste the lavender syrup samples)

Try it in:
🍵 Matcha
🥤 Iced tea or sparkling water
🍰 Lemon cakes
☁️ London Fog
🍸 Lavender Gin Fizz

🍌 #4: Banana

Bright, cheerful, and packed with nostalgia.

Not only is it a kid-favorite, it’s also becoming a favorite for coffee lovers and soda drinkers.

Try it in:
🥞 Pancakes
🍌 Smoothies
🥛 Italian cream sodas
🍹 Mixed with sparkling water
🍯 Or drizzle it over waffles for a banana-split vibe

🎃 #5: Pumpkin Spice (Limited Seasonal Edition!)

Fall in a bottle—because you asked for it.

“Tastes just like autumn should. I stir it into my coffee every morning from September through November.” — Newsletter Subscriber

Think cinnamon, nutmeg, clove, allspice—pure cozy comfort.
Only available in fall… until it sells out. (And it always does.)

❄️ Newest favorite coming - Candy Cane (Holiday Favorite!)

Cool, crisp, and just the right amount of mint.

Perfect for:
🎄 Hot cocoa
☕️ Holiday lattes
🍫 Brownies
🎁 Gifting to your peppermint-loving friends

🛎 They go fast every year.

💬 What’s YOUR Favorite?

We love hearing how you use your syrups—coffee rituals, weekend breakfasts, cocktails, or creative baking experiments.

📸 Tag us in your creations @daddyshomemadesyrups
🗳 Or reply back: what’s YOUR #1 flavor?

Because while we may handcraft every batch, you’re the reason they matter.

Sweetening Lives Naturally, One Jar at a Time!